A Philosopher's Blog

Am I my Own Demon?

Posted in Epistemology, Metaphysics, Philosophy by Michael LaBossiere on September 5, 2016

The problem of the external world is a classic challenge in epistemology (the theory of knowledge). This challenge, which was first presented by the ancient skeptics, is met by proving that what I seem to be experiencing is actually real. As an example, it would require proving that the computer I seem to be typing this on exists outside of my mind.

Some of the early skeptics generated the problem by noting that what seems real could be just a dream, generated in the mind of the dreamer. Descartes added a new element to the problem by considering that an evil demon might be causing him to have experiences of a world that does not actually exist outside of his mind. While the evil demon was said to be devoted to deception, little is said about its motive in this matter. After Descartes there was a move from supernatural to technological deceivers: the classic brain-in-a-vat scenarios that are precursors to the more recent notion of virtual reality. In these philosophical scenarios little is said about the motivation or purpose of the deceit, beyond the desire to epistemically mess with someone. Movies and TV shows do sometimes explore the motives of the deceit. The Matrix trilogy, for example, endeavors to present something of a backstory for the Matrix. While considering the motivation behind the alleged deceit might not bear on the epistemic problem, it does seem a matter worth considering.

The only viable approach to sorting out a possible motivation for the deceit is to consider the nature of the world that is experienced. As various philosophers, such as David Hume, have laid out in their formulations of the problem of evil (the challenge of reconciling God’s perfection with the existence of evil) the world seems to be an awful place. As Hume has noted, it is infested with disease, suffused with suffering, and awash in annoying things. While there are some positive things, there is an overabundance of bad, thus indicating that whatever lies behind the appearances is either not benign or not very competent. This, of course, assumes some purpose behind the deceit. But, perhaps there is deceit without a deceiver and there is no malice. This would make the unreal like what atheists claim about the allegedly real: it is purposeless. However, deceit (like design) seems to suggest an intentional agent and this implies a purpose. This purpose, if there is one, must be consistent with the apparent awfulness of the world.

One approach is to follow Descartes and go with a malicious supernatural deceiver. This being might be acting from mere malice—inflicting both deceit and suffering. Or it might be acting as an agent of punishment for past transgressions on my part. The supernatural hypothesis does have some problems, the main one being that it involves postulating a supernatural entity. Following Occam’s Razor, if I do not need to postulate a supernatural being, then I should not do so.

Another possibility is that I am in technologically created unreal world. In terms of motives consistent with the nature of the world, there are numerous alternatives. One is punishment for some crime or transgression. A problem with this hypothesis is that I have no recollection of a crime or indication that I am serving a sentence. But, it is easy to imagine a system of justice that does not inform prisoners of their crimes during the punishment and that someday I will awaken in the real world, having served my virtual time. It is also easy to imagine that this is merely a system of torment, not a system of punishment. There could be endless speculation about the motives behind such torment. For example, it could be an act of revenge or simple madness. Or even a complete accident. There could be other people here with me; but I have no way of solving the problem of other minds—no way of knowing if those I encounter are fellow prisoners or mere empty constructs. This ignorance does seem to ground a moral approach—since they could be fellow prisoners, I should treat them as such.

A second possibility is that the world is an experiment or simulation of an awful world and I am a construct within that world. Perhaps those conducting it have no idea the inhabitants are suffering; perhaps they do not care; or perhaps the suffering is the experiment. I might even be a researcher, trapped in my own experiment. Given how scientists in the allegedly real world have treated subjects, the idea that this is a simulation of suffering has considerable appeal.

A third possibility is that the world is a game or educational system of some sort. Perhaps I am playing a very lame game of Assessment & Income Tax; perhaps I am in a simulation learning to develop character in the face of an awful world; or perhaps I am just part of the game someone else is playing. All of these are consistent with how the world seems to be.

It is also worth considering the possibility of solipsism: that I am the only being that exists. It could be countered that if I were creating the world, it would be much better for me and far more awesome. After all, I actually write adventures for games and can easily visually a far more enjoyable and fun world. The easy and obvious counter is to point out that when I dream (or, more accurately have nightmares), I experience unpleasant things on a fairly regular basis and have little control. Since my dreams presumably come from me and are often awful, it makes perfect sense that if the world came from me, it would be comparable in its awfulness. The waking world would be more vivid and consistent because I am awake; the dream world less so because of mental fatigue. In this case, I would be my own demon.

 

My Amazon Author Page

My Paizo Page

My DriveThru RPG Page

Follow Me on Twitter

7 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. ajmacdonaldjr said, on September 5, 2016 at 10:29 am

    Philosophically, I guess you would have to admit the possible existence of a spirit world, which could also influence your dreams. Demons, in other words, could be real.

    • ronster12012 said, on September 6, 2016 at 10:01 am

      AJ

      I sometimes wonder if our reality is simply out of phase with other possible realities that are equally as real to those within it as ours is real to us.

    • Michael LaBossiere said, on September 7, 2016 at 1:08 pm

      That is certainly a possibility. Dualism is a viable philosophical position as is the view that evil is objective. So, a spiritual being that is objectively evil, etc. could be a thing. Might even run for president.

  2. david halbstein said, on September 5, 2016 at 2:29 pm

    There is another possibility, and that is that our minds ARE being controlled by some (possibly evil) outside force. If you take a step back from the lofty towers and just take a look around, I think you might agree with me that that is what is really happening. The outside force is, of course, the manipulated media – either promoting the sensational or telling the story the politicians want us to believe.

    During the time that Obamacare was being debated, I remember thinking that over my 50 years or so, I had never had an experience with a doctor or hospital wherein I hadn’t been completely in awe of the level of care I had gotten. That includes emergency room visits, pregnancies (my wife’s, of course, not mine), sick visits, well visits, surgeries – and all over maybe a dozen different healthcare policies including COBRA extensions and private healthcare that I had to drive a 15-year old car to afford. Not only that, I did not KNOW anyone who had had a bad experience with healthcare – including my friend Steven who worked off the books his entire life, had no coverage at all, and suffered two heart attacks, had a stent implanted, and went through several months of cardiac rehab – including transportation and ambulatory care.

    Nonetheless, all I heard – from the media and from those with whom I engaged in political debate was how awful the state of healthcare was in this country.

    Do I believe my own experience? Do I believe a collective experience including my friends and family around me? Or do I believe those who are trying to sell me on the idea of Obamacare, trying to convince me that we are in some awful state?

    The same, of course, is true of so much in this country. We are to believe that assault rifles are the cause of mass murders, with the implication that we are in the midst of an epidemic of gun violence the magnitude of which has never before been seen in this country – yet the statistics show the exact opposite, that gun violence is at a low point and assault rifles don’t even make the list of weapons of choice. Why? Who or what is the evil force trying to deceive me, and for what purpose?

    I can live a life of envy – and that envy would be supported wholeheartedly by so many in this country. After all, why should I suffer so much when the rich just keep getting richer? I can stay up at night resenting that fact, or I can count my blessings and live my life free from all of that angst. The truth is that I don’t care – I have a wife of 30 years and we are as much in love today as when we met – we have two adult children who are happy, intelligent and well-adjusted – and we all take responsibility for ourselves and pay our bills and save our money and just don’t worry about anyone else. Yet, some evil outside force is deceiving us – trying so hard to make us believe that we are victims, that we are suffering, that we should turn to someone (them, as it turns out) to fix this situation for us!

    I could go on and on – this deceit from those in power has been going on throughout history – it’s not just the musings of philosophers, it is a very real situation. Of course, I can choose not to be deceived – or perhaps I am just deceiving myself. But if it’s the latter, I’ll be much happier.

  3. TJB said, on September 5, 2016 at 6:54 pm

    Mike, you are devilish but not demonic.

  4. Eric said, on September 6, 2016 at 8:24 pm

    Real or virtual world, many (most? all?) of us tend to be our own worst enemies. Hence, we’re all our own demons. The real question, then, is…do we have the option not to be?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: