Above & Beyond
Like most people, I saw the story of the couple who had the wrong embryo implanted by their fertility clinic. Obviously, that was one heck of mistake and indicates that the clinic needs to reassess how it labels and tracks embryos. This does provide a rather extreme example of the sorts of easy to fix errors that can cause so much trouble.
What struck me the most about this story was the fact that the couple decided that the embryo would be brought to term and then given to his/her biological parents. When asked about this, the couple made it clear that their decision was based on their values.
Since I teach ethics, I find this very interesting indeed. Naturally, I also find it interesting as a person. It is, to say the least, morally commendable for the woman to go through this experience knowing that she will be giving up the child. As far as I know, she is not receiving any compensation from the other couple for this. Of course, the fertility clinic certainly owes her for the mistake they made.
This does raise the obvious question: what is the right thing to do in that situation?
Related articles by Zemanta
- Ohio Woman Gets Wrong Embryo (blisstree.com)
- WTF: Woman Implanted with Wrong Embryo (VIDEO) (blippitt.com)
- Number of IVF blunders by fertility doctors ‘to rise for fifth consecutive year’ (telegraph.co.uk)
- Clinic to couple: You got the wrong embryos (cnn.com)
- Pregnant mother implanted with wrong embryo to give up baby after IVF blunder (telegraph.co.uk)